Skip to content

Are polycythemia and polycythemia vera the same? A definitive medical guide

5 min read

The prevalence of polycythemia vera is estimated at 44–57 per 100,000 individuals, a condition often confused with the broader term polycythemia. Understanding if are polycythemia and polycythemia vera the same? is crucial for accurate diagnosis and management.

Quick Summary

Polycythemia is a general term for an elevated red blood cell count, while polycythemia vera is a specific, rare type of blood cancer under this umbrella, caused by a genetic mutation.

Key Points

  • General vs. Specific: Polycythemia is a general term for too many red blood cells; polycythemia vera is a specific type of chronic blood cancer.

  • Cause Varies: PV is caused by an acquired genetic mutation (often JAK2), while other types of polycythemia are often secondary to external factors like low oxygen.

  • Distinct Symptoms: PV often presents with unique symptoms like aquagenic pruritus (itching after water) and an enlarged spleen, which are less common in secondary polycythemia.

  • Diagnostic Markers: Low erythropoietin (EPO) levels and the presence of a JAK2 gene mutation are key indicators of PV.

  • Treatment Difference: PV requires ongoing management with specific medications to suppress bone marrow activity, whereas secondary polycythemia is primarily treated by addressing the underlying cause.

  • Higher Risk: PV carries a higher risk of progressing to more aggressive blood disorders like myelofibrosis or acute leukemia.

  • Clotting Risk: Both conditions increase the risk of dangerous blood clots due to thicker blood.

  • Long-Term Management: Accurate diagnosis is essential for proper management and monitoring to minimize complications.

In This Article

What is Polycythemia?

Polycythemia is a blood disorder characterized by an abnormally high number of red blood cells (erythrocytosis). This increase thickens the blood, which can slow its flow and increase the risk of blood clots. Polycythemia can be categorized into two main types: primary and secondary. Primary polycythemia originates from a problem within the bone marrow itself, causing the overproduction of blood cells. Secondary polycythemia, on the other hand, is a response to an underlying external factor, such as a chronic lack of oxygen, which triggers the body to produce more red blood cells.

Symptoms of High Red Blood Cell Count

Regardless of the cause, an excess of red blood cells can lead to a variety of symptoms, including:

  • Fatigue and weakness
  • Headaches and dizziness
  • Blurred vision or vision disturbances
  • Shortness of breath
  • Redness or flushed appearance of the skin

These symptoms can be mild and nonspecific, often leading to the condition being discovered incidentally during a routine blood test.

What is Polycythemia Vera (PV)?

Polycythemia vera is a specific type of primary polycythemia and is classified as a myeloproliferative neoplasm (MPN), a type of slow-growing blood cancer. Unlike other forms of polycythemia, PV is caused by an acquired genetic mutation, most commonly in the JAK2 gene. This mutation causes blood stem cells in the bone marrow to proliferate uncontrollably.

PV is distinct because it can cause an overproduction of not only red blood cells but also white blood cells and platelets. This uncontrolled cell growth leads to thicker blood and an increased risk of serious complications, including blood clots, heart attack, and stroke.

Specific Signs and Symptoms of PV

In addition to general symptoms of polycythemia, PV patients often experience more unique and severe signs:

  • Aquagenic Pruritus: An intense, itchy feeling, especially after exposure to warm water.
  • Erythromelalgia: A painful burning and redness in the hands and feet.
  • Splenomegaly: An enlarged spleen, which may cause pain or fullness in the upper left abdomen.
  • Gout: High levels of uric acid can cause painful joint inflammation, especially in the big toe.

Key Differences: Polycythemia vs. Polycythemia Vera

It is crucial for accurate diagnosis and treatment to understand the distinctions between these two conditions.

Feature Polycythemia (General Term) Polycythemia Vera (Specific Type)
Cause Primarily caused by an external factor, leading to a secondary response, or less commonly, by other primary bone marrow issues. Caused by an acquired genetic mutation (e.g., JAK2) that triggers abnormal cell proliferation in the bone marrow.
Underlying Condition Often a result of another disease, such as sleep apnea, heart disease, or tumors. A primary, intrinsic disease of the bone marrow classified as a blood cancer.
Cells Affected Primarily affects red blood cell count (erythrocytosis). Can cause an increase in red blood cells, white blood cells, and platelets.
Erythropoietin (EPO) Level EPO levels are typically elevated as a response to low oxygen. EPO levels are characteristically low due to the bone marrow’s autonomous overproduction of cells.
Risk of Progression Does not progress to more advanced blood cancers unless the underlying cause is itself malignant. Can progress to other serious blood disorders, such as myelofibrosis or acute myeloid leukemia (AML).

Causes of Secondary Polycythemia

Secondary polycythemia is the most common form and is an appropriate physiological response by the body to a need for more oxygen. The main trigger is chronic tissue hypoxia (low oxygen). Key causes include:

  • Chronic Lung Disease: Conditions like chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) or emphysema limit the lungs' ability to transfer oxygen, leading to compensatory RBC production.
  • High Altitude Living: Lower oxygen concentration at high elevations stimulates the body to produce more red blood cells to compensate.
  • Sleep Apnea: Intermittent pauses in breathing during sleep lead to drops in oxygen levels, causing the kidneys to release more erythropoietin (EPO).
  • Carbon Monoxide Exposure: This can result from heavy smoking and reduces the blood's oxygen-carrying capacity.
  • Certain Tumors: Tumors of the kidney or liver can inappropriately produce EPO, stimulating excessive red blood cell production.

Diagnosis and Testing

Diagnosis for any form of polycythemia begins with a routine blood test, such as a complete blood count (CBC), which reveals the elevated hemoglobin and hematocrit levels. The subsequent diagnostic steps are critical to differentiating between PV and secondary causes:

  1. Erythropoietin (EPO) Level Test: Measures the amount of EPO in the blood. Low levels suggest PV, while high levels point toward secondary polycythemia.
  2. Genetic Testing: Testing for the JAK2 mutation is a major diagnostic criterion for PV and is essential for confirming the disease.
  3. Bone Marrow Biopsy: Provides a definitive look at the bone marrow to see if the blood cell overproduction is primary (intrinsic to the marrow) or secondary.
  4. Further Investigation for Secondary Causes: If EPO is high and the JAK2 mutation is absent, imaging tests or other evaluations may be needed to find the underlying cause, such as a kidney or lung condition.

Treatment Approaches

Treatment is tailored to the specific diagnosis and severity of the condition. For both, the initial goal is often to reduce the red blood cell count to decrease blood viscosity and lower clot risk.

Treating Polycythemia Vera

  • Phlebotomy: Regular blood removal is the most common treatment to reduce blood volume and red cell count.
  • Low-Dose Aspirin: Helps prevent blood clots by inhibiting platelet function.
  • Cytoreductive Therapies: Medications like hydroxyurea, interferon, or ruxolitinib are used to suppress the bone marrow's production of blood cells, especially for high-risk patients or those with severe symptoms.
  • Symptom Management: Treatments for itching, gout, and other specific symptoms are often required.

Treating Secondary Polycythemia

  • Treating the Underlying Cause: The primary focus is on addressing the root issue. This might involve oxygen therapy for lung disease, weight loss for sleep apnea, or surgery to remove a tumor.
  • Phlebotomy: Can be used to relieve symptoms of hyperviscosity, particularly for patients with very high hematocrit levels.

Potential Complications

Both conditions carry risks associated with increased blood viscosity, primarily a heightened risk of blood clots. These clots can lead to serious events like strokes, heart attacks, or deep vein thrombosis (DVT).

For PV specifically, additional complications can arise:

  • Enlarged Spleen: The overworked spleen can become enlarged and cause pain.
  • Leukemic Transformation: Though rare, PV can evolve into more aggressive blood cancers like myelofibrosis or acute myeloid leukemia (AML) over time.
  • Bleeding: Despite increased platelets, they can be dysfunctional, leading to an increased risk of bleeding.

For more detailed information on polycythemia vera, visit the Mayo Clinic resource page.

Conclusion

While the terms are often used interchangeably, polycythemia is a broad category for elevated red blood cell counts, whereas polycythemia vera is a specific, chronic blood cancer. The key differences in origin—genetic mutation versus external trigger—dictate the diagnostic path and long-term management strategy. Accurate differentiation is critical for ensuring patients receive the correct, life-saving treatment and monitoring for complications.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, secondary polycythemia cannot transform into polycythemia vera. They are fundamentally different conditions with distinct causes. PV is caused by an acquired genetic mutation in the bone marrow, while secondary polycythemia is a response to an underlying issue like low oxygen.

The JAK2 mutation is an acquired genetic change that is present in most people with polycythemia vera. This mutation causes blood stem cells to proliferate uncontrollably, leading to the excess production of blood cells. Its presence is a key diagnostic marker for PV.

Diagnosis starts with a blood test showing elevated hemoglobin and hematocrit. To differentiate between PV and secondary polycythemia, doctors measure erythropoietin (EPO) levels, test for the JAK2 gene mutation, and may perform a bone marrow biopsy.

Aquagenic pruritus, or water-induced itching, is a common symptom in polycythemia vera. It is believed to be caused by an abnormal release of histamines or prostaglandins from mast cells, which are overproduced by the mutated blood cells.

Phlebotomy is a procedure for removing blood from the body to lower the red blood cell count. It is a common treatment for both polycythemia vera and severe secondary polycythemia to reduce blood volume and thickness, which helps lower the risk of blood clots.

Yes, polycythemia vera is classified as a rare, slow-growing type of blood cancer called a myeloproliferative neoplasm (MPN). It involves the uncontrolled proliferation of blood cells in the bone marrow.

The most common causes include chronic low oxygen levels from conditions like COPD or sleep apnea, living at high altitudes, and in some cases, tumors that secrete erythropoietin.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.