Skip to content

Is a do a good choice for a primary care physician?

5 min read

According to the American Osteopathic Association, the number of practicing Doctors of Osteopathic Medicine (DOs) in the U.S. has grown by 81% in the last decade, showing their increasing role in healthcare. Deciding if a DO is a good choice for a primary care physician depends on your personal preferences and healthcare philosophy.

Quick Summary

Doctors of Osteopathic Medicine (DOs) are fully licensed physicians who offer comprehensive medical care, including a holistic, whole-person approach to health. Both DOs and MDs undergo rigorous training, and the best choice for a primary care physician depends on your individual needs and preference for their specific care philosophy.

Key Points

  • Holistic Philosophy: DOs are trained in a holistic, whole-person approach, considering lifestyle and environmental factors that can impact your health.

  • Equal Qualifications: Both DOs and MDs complete four years of medical school, residency, and are fully licensed to practice medicine, prescribe medication, and perform surgery in all 50 states.

  • OMT Training: All DOs receive additional hands-on training in Osteopathic Manipulative Treatment (OMT), which can be used to diagnose and treat musculoskeletal issues and aid in healing.

  • Similar Competencies: Both DOs and MDs have extensive medical knowledge and can competently serve as a primary care physician.

  • Personal Preference Matters: The best choice between a DO and an MD depends on your personal preference for their philosophical approach to care and your rapport with the individual doctor.

  • Higher PCP Rate: DOs are more likely to specialize in primary care fields, making them a common choice for those seeking a family doctor.

In This Article

Understanding the DO Philosophy

A Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (DO) is a fully licensed physician in all 50 states, trained to diagnose, treat, and prevent illness. The defining difference between a DO and a Doctor of Medicine (MD) lies in the DO's philosophical approach to patient care, which is centered on the concept of holistic, whole-person medicine.

Unlike the more traditional allopathic model practiced by MDs, which often focuses on disease-specific diagnosis and treatment, osteopathic medicine views the body as an interconnected system of mind, body, and spirit. DOs are trained to look beyond a patient's symptoms to understand how lifestyle, environment, and physical structure impact overall well-being.

The Whole-Person Approach

The tenets of osteopathic medicine mean that a DO will take into account a variety of factors when assessing your health:

  • Body Unity: Recognizing that all body systems are interrelated, an issue in one area can manifest as symptoms elsewhere. A DO will consider this interconnectedness during diagnosis and treatment.
  • Self-Healing: The osteopathic philosophy holds that the body has an innate ability to heal itself. DOs work to support and facilitate these natural healing processes.
  • Structure-Function Interrelation: The structure of the body (muscles, nerves, bones) is directly related to its function. A DO is trained to use manual techniques to diagnose and treat structural problems that may affect function.

The Role of Osteopathic Manipulative Treatment (OMT)

One of the most notable features of a DO's training is the inclusion of Osteopathic Manipulative Treatment (OMT). This hands-on technique is used to diagnose, treat, and prevent a range of medical conditions, and it involves applying gentle pressure, stretching, and resistance to help relieve pain, promote healing, and restore proper function.

It is important to note that while all DOs are trained in OMT, they are not chiropractors, and they do not always use OMT in every appointment. Its use depends on the patient's condition and needs, but the training behind it informs a DO's overall diagnostic approach.

DOs and MDs: A Comparison for Primary Care

When choosing a primary care physician (PCP), it's useful to compare the two credentials. While their philosophies differ, their capabilities are largely the same. Both types of doctors complete four years of medical school and undergo a residency program to specialize. They are both licensed to practice medicine, perform surgery, and prescribe medication.

Feature Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (DO) Doctor of Medicine (MD)
Core Philosophy Whole-person, holistic approach. Focus on prevention and the body's self-healing capabilities. Traditional, allopathic medicine. Emphasis on diagnosing and treating specific diseases and symptoms.
Training Standard medical curriculum plus additional training in Osteopathic Manipulative Treatment (OMT). Standard medical curriculum with a focus on evidence-based, conventional treatment methods.
Licensing Exams Primarily take the COMLEX-USA, though many also take the USMLE. Primarily take the USMLE.
Residency Compete for the same residency spots as MDs through the single accreditation system. Compete for the same residency spots as DOs.
Practice Scope Fully licensed and able to practice in any specialty. Fully licensed and able to practice in any specialty.
Likelihood of PCP Historically, a higher percentage of DOs enter primary care fields, such as family medicine. Many MDs also enter primary care, though a higher percentage often go into other specialties.

Who is the Right Choice for You?

The decision between a DO and an MD for your primary care rests on personal preference. If you value a physician who is trained to consider your overall well-being—including lifestyle, environment, and musculoskeletal health—a DO may be a great fit. This is particularly true if you appreciate a non-invasive, hands-on approach to pain or chronic conditions, though you should clarify if the specific DO incorporates OMT into their practice.

Some MDs are also adopting a more holistic approach, but it is a foundational component of osteopathic training. If you are comfortable with a more traditional focus on disease management, either a DO or MD can provide excellent care. Many people report little to no difference in their patient experience, and both are equally qualified to serve as your PCP.

What to Consider When Choosing Your PCP

Beyond the Degree: Finding the Right Fit

While the DO vs. MD distinction is helpful, it shouldn't be the only factor in your decision. The individual doctor's personality, communication style, and rapport with patients are often more important for a successful long-term relationship. When looking for a new PCP, consider these aspects:

  1. Bedside Manner: Do you feel comfortable asking questions and openly discussing your health concerns? A strong doctor-patient relationship is built on trust and communication.
  2. Referral Network: What specialists do they work with? A PCP's network of referrals can be important, especially for complex health issues.
  3. Logistics: Consider the clinic's location, office hours, and insurance coverage. Practical considerations like these can have a significant impact on your healthcare experience.
  4. Patient Reviews: Look up feedback from other patients. Online reviews can offer insight into a doctor's approach, wait times, and overall patient satisfaction.

The Growing Presence of DOs

DOs are a fast-growing segment of the healthcare landscape, and they hold prominent positions across medicine. Many serve as primary care physicians, especially in rural and underserved areas, where their emphasis on preventive and whole-person care is highly valued. The increasing number of DOs entering the workforce ensures that patients will have more options for finding a physician who aligns with their healthcare needs and personal preferences.

Making Your Final Decision

To make an informed choice, consider your priorities. If preventive care and a holistic perspective are important to you, a DO may be a particularly good option. If a traditional, disease-focused approach is what you prefer, either a DO or MD is capable of providing excellent care. Ultimately, the best primary care physician is one with whom you feel comfortable and confident in your healthcare journey.

Visit the American Osteopathic Association's website to learn more about the field of osteopathic medicine.

Conclusion: Your Health, Your Choice

Both Doctors of Osteopathic Medicine (DOs) and Doctors of Medicine (MDs) are qualified, licensed physicians who can serve as your primary care provider. The key distinction lies in the osteopathic philosophy of treating the whole person, which emphasizes the body's interconnectedness and natural healing abilities. For those who prefer a more hands-on, holistic approach that considers lifestyle and musculoskeletal health, a DO is an excellent choice. However, as the lines between the two degrees blur in modern medicine, the individual doctor's qualities and rapport with you as a patient are often the most important factors in your decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

The main difference is their philosophical approach. DOs are trained in a holistic, whole-person approach that considers the mind, body, and spirit, while MDs follow a more traditional, allopathic model focused on diagnosing and treating specific diseases.

Yes, both DOs and MDs undergo rigorous medical training, are fully licensed, and can prescribe medication, perform surgery, and work in any specialty. They are equally qualified to provide primary care.

All DOs receive training in OMT, but not all use it regularly in their practice. Some may incorporate it frequently, while others only use it for specific conditions or when deemed appropriate for the patient.

DOs can practice in any medical specialty, just like MDs. While a higher percentage of DOs choose primary care fields, they are also found in specialties like surgery, emergency medicine, and pediatrics.

No, while both involve manual techniques, they are different disciplines. DOs are fully licensed physicians who incorporate OMT into comprehensive medical care, unlike chiropractors who focus exclusively on the spine.

For most primary care needs, either a DO or MD can provide excellent treatment. The choice often depends more on your preference for a holistic versus a traditional approach, as well as the individual doctor's personality.

You can find a DO using the search tool on the American Osteopathic Association's website. Your local osteopathic medical association or hospital may also provide referrals.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.