Skip to content

A Guide on How to Buy Shoes with Different Sized Feet

4 min read

According to the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society, up to 60% of people have one foot that is larger than the other, often by a half size or more. This guide on How to buy shoes with different sized feet? provides authoritative, actionable advice for finding a comfortable and supportive fit, ensuring your foot health isn't compromised by improper footwear.

Quick Summary

Finding the right footwear involves several strategic approaches, including being professionally measured, shopping for mismatched pairs from specialized retailers, or utilizing insoles and lacing techniques to adjust the fit of the smaller foot. Prioritizing comfort and fit for the larger foot is generally the best starting point.

Key Points

  • Embrace the Asymmetry: Accept that different-sized feet are common and normal, not a flaw.

  • Go by the Larger Foot: Always choose shoes that comfortably fit your larger foot, using adjustments for the smaller one.

  • Get a Professional Fitting: Have both feet measured accurately, preferably later in the day.

  • Utilize Strategic Solutions: Explore options like specialized mismatched-pair retailers, insoles, and lacing techniques.

  • Consider the 'Two-Pair' Strategy: If budget allows, buying two pairs in different sizes is the most reliable way to achieve a perfect fit.

  • Prioritize Comfort Over All Else: A well-fitting shoe is crucial for foot health and overall comfort.

In This Article

Understanding the Reality of Asymmetrical Feet

It's a common misconception that our bodies are perfectly symmetrical. For most people, one foot is slightly larger than the other. This difference can be minor, unnoticeable in everyday life, or significant enough to cause discomfort and difficulty when purchasing shoes.

Why Your Feet Are Different Sizes

Several factors can contribute to feet of varying sizes:

  • Genetics: It's simply the natural way your body developed.
  • Dominance: Your dominant leg often has a slightly larger foot, similar to how a dominant hand is slightly stronger.
  • Aging: Over time, tendons and ligaments can loosen, causing feet to widen and lengthen.
  • Medical Conditions: Certain conditions, like bunions or hammer toes, can alter the size and shape of one foot.
  • Injury or Trauma: Past injuries can lead to swelling or other changes that permanently affect foot size.

The Professional Measurement: Your First Step

Before you start shopping, get a professional measurement. Most shoe stores and podiatrist offices have a Brannock Device, the standard tool for measuring feet.

What to Expect During a Professional Fitting

  1. Measure Both Feet: Always measure both feet, especially when they feel different. Measure length, width, and arch length.
  2. Go by the Larger Foot: The golden rule of shoe fitting is to always buy shoes that accommodate your larger foot comfortably. Trying to squeeze your larger foot into a shoe that fits the smaller one is a recipe for pain and foot problems.
  3. Timing is Everything: Your feet swell throughout the day. For the most accurate measurement, get fitted at the end of the day when your feet are at their largest.

Expert Strategies for Mismatched Feet

Once you know your true sizes, you can employ several strategies to find the perfect pair of shoes.

Buy Two Pairs of Shoes

While seemingly expensive, this is a foolproof method for a perfect fit. Some companies, especially those catering to people with asymmetrical feet, sell individual shoes rather than pairs. For example, a company might allow you to purchase a size 9 for your right foot and a size 8.5 for your left.

Utilize Specialized Retailers

There are niche retailers that understand the challenges of different-sized feet and offer customizable or individual shoe options. These companies often focus on athletic or orthopedic footwear but are becoming more common in other sectors as well.

The Insole Solution

For a slight size difference, a simple solution is to add a cushioned insole to the shoe on your smaller foot. This fills the extra space and creates a more snug, supportive fit. For more significant differences, consider a thicker orthotic insole that offers more support and bulk.

Lacing Techniques to the Rescue

Altering your lacing can help adjust the fit for your smaller foot. A tight, secure lacing on the smaller foot and a slightly looser one on the larger foot can make a world of difference. Here's a quick guide:

  • Runner's Loop: This lacing technique is excellent for securing your heel and preventing slippage, especially on the smaller foot.
  • Skip Lacing: If your shoe feels too tight in certain areas, skipping an eyelet can reduce pressure. Conversely, using all eyelets and ensuring the lace is pulled taut can improve the fit for your smaller foot.

Comparison of Shoe-Buying Strategies for Asymmetrical Feet

Strategy Pros Cons Ideal For
Buying Mismatched Pairs Perfect fit guaranteed. Ideal for significant size differences. Potentially higher cost. Limited availability. Significant size differences, prioritizing a perfect fit.
Using Insoles Cost-effective and flexible. Easily adjustable. Might not be effective for large size differences. Can alter the feel of the shoe. Minor size differences, those on a budget.
Lacing Techniques Free and easy to implement. Highly customizable. Only addresses minor fit issues. Requires regular adjustments. Fine-tuning the fit for small discrepancies.
Custom Footwear Made specifically for your feet. Accommodates all sizes. Very expensive and time-consuming. Severe asymmetry or complex foot conditions.

Tips for Shopping, Online and In-Store

In-Store Shopping

  • Bring the Right Socks: Wear the socks you plan to wear with the shoes to get the most accurate fit.
  • Test Them Out: Walk around the store. Jog a little. Make sure the larger foot is comfortable and the smaller foot feels secure.
  • Trust Your Gut: If something feels off, it probably is. Don't compromise comfort for style.

Online Shopping

  • Understand Return Policies: Before purchasing, make sure you can return shoes easily if the fit isn't right. Check for specific policies regarding mismatched sizes.
  • Read Reviews: Look for reviews from other customers with similar foot-sizing challenges. Their experiences can be invaluable.
  • Measure At Home: While not as precise as a professional, measuring your feet at home can be a good starting point. Here’s a detailed guide on how to measure your feet properly from the American Podiatric Medical Association.

Conclusion

Living with different-sized feet doesn't mean you have to sacrifice comfort or style. By embracing the fact that your feet are unique and employing smart shopping strategies, you can find the perfect footwear. Whether it's seeking out specialized retailers, using insoles, or simply adjusting your lacing, the right approach will lead to happy, healthy feet. Always remember to prioritize the larger foot and listen to your body—comfort is key to preventing long-term foot issues.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, it is very common. Studies suggest that a majority of people have one foot that is slightly larger than the other. The difference is often negligible, but for some, it's significant enough to impact shoe sizing.

You should measure your feet in the evening or at the end of the day. Feet tend to swell throughout the day, so this ensures you are accommodating for the maximum size.

For athletic shoes, a perfect fit is crucial. In addition to measuring correctly, look for brands that offer individual sizing or consider buying two different-sized pairs. Using specialized lacing techniques is also highly effective for a secure fit during exercise.

Insoles are best for correcting a half-size or smaller difference. For larger discrepancies, they may not be enough to provide a stable and comfortable fit, and you might consider other options like custom footwear or buying mismatched pairs.

For most people, it's not necessary. However, if the size difference is significant, you experience pain, or have underlying foot issues, a podiatrist can provide tailored advice and recommendations for custom orthotics or footwear.

Yes. Squeezing your larger foot into a shoe that is too small can lead to a host of problems, including bunions, calluses, hammertoes, and general foot pain. It is always best to fit the larger foot.

Absolutely. Strategic lacing is a free and effective way to secure the shoe on your smaller foot. Techniques like the runner's loop can help lock the heel in place and prevent slipping.

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.