Understanding the Models of Disability
Before delving into the specific components, it's crucial to understand the different conceptual models that frame our perception of disability. Two primary models, the medical and the social, provide contrasting perspectives on the issue.
The Medical Model vs. The Social Model
Historically, the medical model viewed disability as an individual's problem, stemming from a physical or mental impairment that needed to be cured or compensated for. It focuses on the individual's deficits, placing the responsibility on the person to adapt to society. For example, a person using a wheelchair was seen as having a mobility issue that required fixing.
In contrast, the social model of disability reframes the issue, asserting that disability is created by an inaccessible and exclusionary society, not by an individual's impairment. Under this model, the disability is not the wheelchair but the stairs that prevent the person from entering a building. It emphasizes that societal attitudes, policies, and the built environment are the real disabling factors, and that true solutions require systemic change to ensure full participation for all.
The WHO's Biopsychosocial Model (ICF)
Bridging the gap between the medical and social models, the World Health Organization's International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) provides a comprehensive framework. It acknowledges that disability results from a complex interaction between a person's health condition and their contextual factors, which include both environmental and personal elements.
The Core Components of the ICF Model
The ICF framework identifies several key components that shape the experience of disability. These components interact dynamically to influence an individual's functioning and participation in society.
1. Health Condition
At the center of the ICF model is the individual's health condition, which can include diseases, disorders, injuries, or other health-related states. This is the starting point, but it's not the sole determinant of disability. For instance, a person with diabetes may or may not experience limitations depending on its severity and management.
2. Body Functions and Structures (Impairments)
This component refers to the physiological functions of body systems and anatomical parts, respectively. An impairment is a problem in body function or structure, such as the loss of a limb, visual impairment, or memory loss.
- Body Functions: Examples include mental functions (e.g., cognition, emotion), sensory functions (e.g., seeing, hearing), and functions of the musculoskeletal system.
- Body Structures: This refers to the anatomical components of the body, such as organs, limbs, and their components.
3. Activities (Activity Limitations)
Activities refer to the execution of a task or action by an individual. An activity limitation occurs when a person has difficulty executing a task, such as walking, hearing, or problem-solving. This component is focused on the individual level.
4. Participation (Participation Restrictions)
Participation is an individual's involvement in life situations, such as working, going to school, or engaging in social activities. A participation restriction is a problem a person may experience in involvement in life situations. For example, being unable to find accessible transportation might restrict participation in social and recreational events.
The Role of Contextual Factors
Beyond the individual's health condition and body functions, a person's context plays a critical role in determining their experience of disability. The ICF model breaks this down into two categories.
Environmental Factors
These are external influences on a person's functioning and disability. They include the physical environment, social context, and attitudes of others.
- Physical Environment: The accessibility of buildings, transportation, and public spaces.
- Social Context: The availability of social support networks, services, and policies.
- Attitudes: Societal beliefs, stigma, and biases towards people with disabilities.
Personal Factors
These are internal influences on functioning and disability and are not part of the health condition itself. They include characteristics like age, gender, education, and lifestyle. These factors can influence how a person adapts to their condition.
A Deeper Look into Environmental Barriers
The CDC identifies several types of barriers that can limit the functioning and participation of people with disabilities. These often interact with one another to create a more significant challenge.
- Attitudinal Barriers: Prejudices or stereotypes that lead to discrimination.
- Communication Barriers: Difficulty for people with disabilities to receive or convey information.
- Physical Barriers: Inaccessible built environments, like a lack of ramps or elevators.
- Policy Barriers: Deficiencies in policies and laws that hinder involvement.
Comparison of Disability Models
Feature | Medical Model | Social Model | Biopsychosocial (ICF) Model |
---|---|---|---|
Problem Origin | The individual's impairment | The inaccessible, ableist society | The interaction between health conditions and contextual factors |
Focus | Individual's limitations and deficits | Societal barriers and discrimination | Functioning, activities, participation, and context |
Solution | Cure or fix the individual | Change society to be inclusive | Improve functioning by addressing both individual and environmental factors |
Responsibility | The individual, with support from medical professionals | Society at large, including policymakers and the public | Shared responsibility between the individual and society |
Perspective | Clinical, rehabilitative approach | Human rights, civil rights approach | Comprehensive, holistic approach |
Conclusion: A Holistic View of Disability
Understanding what are the key components of disability requires moving beyond a simplistic view of medical impairments. A person's experience is shaped by a complex interplay of their health condition, bodily functions, the tasks they can perform, their social participation, and the surrounding environment and personal attributes. By recognizing the full scope of these components, we can better appreciate the diverse reality of living with a disability and focus on creating a more inclusive, accessible, and supportive society for everyone. Understanding the nuances of the ICF model is vital for designing effective policies and healthcare strategies that address the full spectrum of a person's needs.
For more information on inclusive policies and the social model of disability, refer to the New Zealand Disability Strategy.