Skip to content

What is the difference between primary amyloidosis and secondary amyloidosis?

4 min read

Affecting about 8 out of every 1 million people annually, amyloidosis is a rare group of diseases caused by abnormal protein buildup. Understanding what is the difference between primary amyloidosis and secondary amyloidosis is crucial, as their underlying causes and treatment approaches are distinct.

Quick Summary

Primary (AL) amyloidosis stems from a bone marrow disorder where abnormal plasma cells produce faulty light chain proteins, while secondary (AA) amyloidosis develops as a complication of an existing chronic inflammatory condition, causing serum amyloid A protein to accumulate.

Key Points

  • Origin: Primary (AL) amyloidosis starts with abnormal plasma cells in the bone marrow, while secondary (AA) results from chronic inflammation.

  • Protein Type: The deposited protein in primary amyloidosis is a light chain (AL), whereas in secondary amyloidosis, it is serum amyloid A (AA).

  • Affected Organs: Primary amyloidosis commonly affects the heart and kidneys, but can be widespread, while secondary typically targets the kidneys, liver, and spleen.

  • Treatment Strategy: Treatment for primary amyloidosis focuses on eliminating the faulty plasma cells, while treatment for secondary focuses on managing the underlying inflammatory disease.

  • Associated Conditions: Primary amyloidosis can be associated with multiple myeloma, while secondary is linked to diseases like rheumatoid arthritis.

  • Diagnosis is Crucial: Accurate diagnosis of the amyloidosis type is essential because it determines the correct, highly specific treatment plan.

In This Article

Understanding Systemic Amyloidosis

Amyloidosis refers to a group of diseases where abnormal proteins, known as amyloid fibrils, build up in tissues and organs, disrupting their normal function. Because these deposits can spread throughout the body, the condition is often referred to as systemic amyloidosis. While the symptoms can overlap, the precise type of protein involved is what fundamentally differentiates one form of amyloidosis from another, including the distinction between primary and secondary types.

Primary (AL) Amyloidosis

Primary amyloidosis, or AL amyloidosis (for Amyloid Light chain), is the most common form in many Western countries. Its origin lies in the bone marrow, making it a hematological disorder.

Causes and Protein Type

AL amyloidosis is caused by an underlying disorder of plasma cells in the bone marrow. Plasma cells are a type of white blood cell responsible for producing antibodies. In AL amyloidosis, these plasma cells become abnormal and produce an overabundance of misfolded immunoglobulin light chain proteins. These faulty light chains then aggregate and deposit as amyloid fibrils in various organs.

Affected Organs

Since the amyloid fibrils travel through the bloodstream, AL amyloidosis can affect many different organ systems. Common sites for protein deposition include:

  • Heart (cardiac amyloidosis): Leading to heart failure, irregular heartbeat, and shortness of breath.
  • Kidneys: Resulting in kidney damage, which can cause foamy urine due to protein leakage.
  • Nervous System: Causing numbness, tingling, or weakness in the extremities, and sometimes carpal tunnel syndrome.
  • Gastrointestinal Tract: Potentially causing diarrhea, constipation, or macroglossia (enlarged tongue).
  • Skin: Manifesting as easy bruising, skin thickening, or purple patches around the eyes.

Diagnosis and Treatment

Diagnosis typically involves a combination of tests to confirm the presence of amyloid deposits and identify the specific protein type.

  1. Blood and Urine Tests: To check for the presence of abnormal light chain proteins.
  2. Tissue Biopsy: A sample of tissue, often from abdominal fat or bone marrow, is examined under a microscope after special staining.
  3. Imaging Tests: Echocardiograms, MRIs, and other scans may be used to assess organ involvement, especially the heart and kidneys.

Treatment for AL amyloidosis focuses on eliminating the abnormal plasma cells producing the faulty protein. This is similar to the approach for multiple myeloma, a related blood cancer. Treatment options include:

  • Chemotherapy
  • Corticosteroids
  • Stem cell transplantation

Secondary (AA) Amyloidosis

Secondary, or AA amyloidosis (for Amyloid A), is the result of another long-term inflammatory disease. The amyloid deposits are a complication of the underlying chronic condition.

Causes and Protein Type

AA amyloidosis is caused by prolonged, high levels of a protein called serum amyloid A (SAA). This protein is produced by the liver in response to inflammation. In chronic inflammatory diseases, the liver continuously produces SAA, which can then misfold and form amyloid fibrils.

Associated Conditions and Affected Organs

Conditions commonly associated with AA amyloidosis include:

  • Rheumatoid Arthritis
  • Chronic Infections (e.g., tuberculosis)
  • Familial Mediterranean Fever
  • Inflammatory Bowel Disease

Unlike AL amyloidosis, AA amyloidosis has a more specific pattern of organ involvement. The most common site for amyloid deposits is the kidneys. Other organs that can be affected include:

  • Spleen
  • Liver
  • Adrenal Glands

Diagnosis and Treatment

Diagnosis of AA amyloidosis involves a similar process to AL, confirming amyloid deposits and identifying the protein type. However, the crucial first step is to identify the underlying inflammatory disease causing the SAA overproduction.

  1. Identify Underlying Condition: A thorough medical history and examination are performed.
  2. Blood Tests: To measure levels of SAA.
  3. Biopsy: To confirm the presence of amyloid deposits and use specific staining to identify AA protein.

The primary treatment for AA amyloidosis is to aggressively treat the underlying chronic inflammatory condition. By controlling the inflammation, the production of SAA is reduced, which in turn halts the progression of amyloid deposition.

Key Differences: Primary (AL) vs. Secondary (AA) Amyloidosis

The table below summarizes the key distinguishing factors between the two types of amyloidosis.

Feature Primary (AL) Amyloidosis Secondary (AA) Amyloidosis
Underlying Cause A disorder of plasma cells in the bone marrow. A complication of chronic inflammatory disease.
Amyloid Protein Immunoglobulin Light Chains. Serum Amyloid A (SAA) Protein.
Primary Organ Involvement Heart, kidneys, nerves, gastrointestinal tract, and skin. Kidneys, liver, and spleen.
Treatment Focus Targeting the abnormal plasma cells. Controlling the underlying inflammatory condition.
Typical Patient Profile Often older adults, without a prior inflammatory disease history. Patients with a known history of a chronic inflammatory condition.

Conclusion: Precision is Key for Effective Treatment

While both primary and secondary amyloidosis result from the build-up of abnormal protein, their origins are fundamentally different. Primary (AL) amyloidosis is a primary blood disorder, whereas secondary (AA) amyloidosis is a consequence of another chronic inflammatory illness. This distinction is critical for physicians because it dictates the entire treatment strategy. Targeting the plasma cells in AL versus controlling the inflammation in AA means the path to managing the condition and improving patient outcomes is entirely dependent on accurate typing of the disease. For more information, consult reliable medical resources such as the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Center.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, in Western countries like the United States, primary (AL) amyloidosis is the most common form of systemic amyloidosis. Secondary (AA) amyloidosis is less common, especially with improvements in managing chronic inflammatory diseases.

Yes, primary (AL) amyloidosis is a disorder of plasma cells and is often associated with other conditions involving these cells, such as multiple myeloma.

Secondary (AA) amyloidosis is diagnosed by identifying amyloid deposits in a biopsy and confirming the presence of the AA protein, but critically, it also requires identifying the underlying chronic inflammatory disease causing the protein overproduction.

While symptoms can overlap, the specific organs most commonly affected differ. Primary (AL) often involves the heart and nervous system more prominently, while secondary (AA) frequently impacts the kidneys, liver, and spleen.

Yes, the treatments are distinct. Primary amyloidosis treatment targets the abnormal plasma cells producing the light chain protein, while secondary amyloidosis treatment focuses on controlling the underlying inflammatory condition to stop the production of the SAA protein.

The severity depends on the extent of organ damage, not just the type. However, primary (AL) amyloidosis has historically been associated with a poorer prognosis due to the difficulty of treating the underlying plasma cell disorder, though newer treatments have improved outcomes.

Secondary (AA) amyloidosis can sometimes be managed or even halted if the underlying chronic inflammatory disease is effectively controlled or treated, which stops the production of the amyloid-forming SAA protein.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.