A Different Era: Tobacco in Mid-Century Healthcare
Prior to the 1980s, smoking was widely accepted in hospitals, with both medical professionals and patients smoking freely indoors. Some hospitals provided ashtrays and sold cigarettes in gift shops. This was consistent with societal norms of the time, and some healthcare workers even appeared in cigarette advertisements.
Experienced healthcare staff recall a time when smoking was permitted at nurses' stations and in patient rooms. Special arrangements were sometimes made for patients on oxygen to smoke. For certain psychiatric patients, smoking was considered a right, and some units supplied cigarettes. Smoking was prevalent throughout hospitals, including staff areas, waiting rooms, and even intensive care units.
The Turning Point: Growing Health Concerns and Evidence
The shift began with increasing evidence of smoking's health risks. The 1964 Surgeon General's report was a key event, though policy changes were gradual. Growing awareness of the dangers of secondhand smoke, which causes heart disease and lung cancer in non-smokers, further highlighted the conflict between smoking and a healing environment. Secondhand smoke posed significant risks to hospital staff.
Public opinion changed, and the anti-smoking movement grew. Clean indoor air laws and the ban on airline smoking in the late 1980s increased pressure on hospitals to go smoke-free.
Factors Influencing the Change
Several factors contributed to the end of smoking in hospitals:
- Medical Evidence: Overwhelming scientific proof of the harms of smoking and secondhand smoke.
- Accreditation Standards: The Joint Commission mandated smoke-free facilities for accreditation.
- Employee Health and Safety: The need to protect hospital employees from secondhand smoke.
- Public Image and Perception: Hospitals sought to align their image with health promotion.
- Liability Concerns: Risks associated with exposing non-smokers to secondhand smoke.
The Implementation of Smoke-Free Hospital Policies
The major change occurred in the early 1990s. In 1991, the Joint Commission announced that accredited hospitals had to be smoke-free by December 31, 1993. This mandate was the primary driver for hospitals to adopt strict no-smoking policies nationwide. By 1994, most U.S. hospitals complied.
Hospitals implemented various strategies to enforce these policies:
- Clear Communication: Informing patients and visitors of the policy through signage and upon admission.
- Cessation Support: Offering nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) to help patients manage withdrawal.
- Removing Infrastructure: Eliminating ashtrays and designated smoking areas.
- Staff Training: Training staff to enforce the policy with patients and visitors.
- Campus-wide Bans: Extending the prohibition to all hospital grounds, including parking areas.
Comparison of Hospital Smoking Policies
Feature | Pre-1990s (Example: 1970s) | Modern Day (Post-1993) |
---|---|---|
General Policy | Widely permitted, with designated smoking lounges or patient rooms. | Strict, campus-wide bans on all tobacco and e-cigarette products. |
Staff Smoking | Common practice in nursing stations and break rooms. | Prohibited on hospital property; failure to comply can result in disciplinary action. |
Patient Access | Patients could smoke in their rooms or designated areas; hospitals sometimes sold cigarettes. | Patients are expected to abstain; NRT is offered for nicotine addiction management. |
Availability of Tobacco | Cigarette vending machines and gift shop sales were common. | No tobacco products are sold or provided on campus. |
Exposure to Secondhand Smoke | High risk for patients, staff, and visitors, including those with respiratory issues. | Minimized by comprehensive smoke-free policies. |
Challenges and Nuances: The Case of Psychiatric Units
Implementing bans in psychiatric units presented unique challenges, as some staff feared patient agitation or withdrawal. Historically, some exceptions were made, with smoking sometimes seen as a way to build rapport or a patient's right.
However, research indicated that smoke-free policies in psychiatric settings did not increase aggression and improved patient health. Courts did not uphold a "right to smoke" for psychiatric patients, prioritizing the health of all individuals in the hospital.
A Radical Transformation in Healthcare
The move to prohibit smoking in hospitals signifies a major public health achievement, showing how medical evidence, public pressure, and regulation can alter established practices. Today, smoke-free hospitals are essential for patient care, staff well-being, and public health. This history underscores the progress made in aligning healthcare practices with its core mission.
Visit the CDC's site for more information on tobacco control and smoking prevention to learn about current initiatives and resources.