Skip to content

What is the argument for a bidet?

3 min read

Globally, bidets are the norm, not the exception, with over 85% of people worldwide using water-based cleaning methods instead of just paper. What is the argument for a bidet, and why is this bathroom fixture gaining such traction in the United States?

Quick Summary

Bidets provide a superior, more hygienic cleaning experience than toilet paper, reduce environmental waste, and offer significant long-term cost savings. The case for a bidet combines benefits for health, sustainability, and comfort.

Key Points

  • Superior Hygiene: Water-based cleaning is far more effective and sanitary than wiping with dry paper, reducing bacterial residue and providing a fresher feel.

  • Environmental Savings: Bidets significantly decrease the demand for toilet paper, saving millions of trees, reducing water consumption during manufacturing, and lowering carbon emissions.

  • Cost-Effective: While requiring a small initial investment, a bidet leads to substantial long-term savings by eliminating the recurring cost of toilet paper.

  • Gentle and Soothing: The gentle water stream is ideal for sensitive skin and can provide relief for conditions like hemorrhoids and anal fissures, preventing irritation from abrasive wiping.

  • Enhanced Comfort: Modern bidets offer customizable features like adjustable water pressure, temperature, and drying options for a more comfortable and luxurious bathroom experience.

In This Article

A More Hygienic and Thorough Clean

For most people, the most compelling reason to switch to a bidet is the promise of a superior clean. Wiping with dry paper often leaves residue and can smear bacteria, whereas a gentle, focused stream of water effectively washes it away. This results in a cleaner, fresher feeling that cannot be achieved with paper alone.

Health and Comfort Benefits

From a health perspective, bidets offer several notable advantages:

  • Reduced irritation: For those with sensitive skin, hemorrhoids, or anal fissures, the friction from toilet paper can be painful and cause further irritation. A bidet's soft water stream is far gentler.
  • Prevents bacterial spread: Hand-to-paper contact can risk spreading bacteria. A bidet significantly reduces this, improving overall sanitation.
  • Aids mobility issues: For people with arthritis, mobility limitations, or injuries, a bidet allows for a more independent and dignified bathroom experience without physical strain.

Medical Support for Water Cleaning

Many medical professionals recommend bidets, especially for patients with certain conditions. Postpartum women, for example, find a gentle water wash more soothing and hygienic. The enhanced cleaning also reduces the risk of urinary tract infections (UTIs) by preventing bacterial transfer from the rectum to the urethra.

Significant Environmental Advantages

The environmental argument for a bidet is a powerful one. The production of toilet paper is a resource-intensive process, demanding vast quantities of water, trees, and energy. Making the switch can have a substantial positive impact.

The Resource Consumption of Toilet Paper

Consider these statistics:

  1. Water Usage: It is estimated that producing a single roll of toilet paper requires over 37 gallons of water. By contrast, a bidet uses only a fraction of a gallon per wash.
  2. Deforestation: The demand for toilet paper contributes to deforestation, particularly the clearing of ancient forests that are vital for combating climate change. Using a bidet drastically reduces the amount of paper needed, preserving these natural resources.
  3. Carbon Footprint: The entire process, from logging and manufacturing to packaging and transportation, contributes significantly to greenhouse gas emissions. Fewer rolls mean a smaller carbon footprint.

Long-Term Economic Savings

While the initial cost of a bidet attachment or toilet seat is a one-time expense, the long-term financial benefits are substantial. For a standard American household, toilet paper is a recurring and often overlooked cost that adds up over time.

A Cost-Effective Solution

By replacing or significantly reducing toilet paper usage, a bidet pays for itself over the years. Premium bidets with features like heated seats or dryers also offer a more luxurious experience while still proving more cost-effective in the long run. The money saved on toilet paper can offset the initial investment surprisingly quickly.

Enhanced Comfort and Modern Convenience

Modern bidets are a far cry from the classic standalone basins. Today's models offer an array of features designed to maximize comfort and convenience:

  • Adjustable settings: Customizable water pressure, temperature, and nozzle position ensure a personalized and comfortable experience.
  • Heated seats: A heated seat is a welcome luxury, especially during colder months.
  • Warm air dryers: After washing, a warm air dryer can complete the process, eliminating the need for any paper at all.
  • Easy installation: Many modern bidet attachments can be self-installed onto an existing toilet in under an hour, making the upgrade simple and accessible.

Bidets vs. Toilet Paper

Feature Bidet Toilet Paper
Cleanliness Uses water for a thorough, superior wash. Involves wiping, which can leave residue and spread bacteria.
Hygiene More sanitary, reduces direct contact with waste. Increases risk of bacterial spread, can cause irritation.
Environment Reduces tree and water consumption. Lower carbon footprint. Uses significant water, trees, and energy for production. Higher carbon footprint.
Cost High initial investment, but significant long-term savings. Low initial cost, but high recurring expense over time.
Plumbing Reduces the risk of toilet clogs from excess paper. Frequent use can lead to clogs and expensive plumbing repairs.

Conclusion: A Clear Argument for a Bidet

The argument for a bidet is clear and multi-faceted. From superior personal hygiene and health benefits to a dramatically reduced environmental impact and long-term cost savings, the transition away from dry paper wiping makes logical sense. It is a simple yet powerful upgrade that enhances daily comfort and aligns with modern values of sustainability and cleanliness. As awareness grows, it is no wonder this once-uncommon fixture is becoming the new standard in American bathrooms. For more information on the environmental impact of paper products, consider reading up on the subject from reputable sources, such as the Natural Resources Defense Council.

Frequently Asked Questions

Most modern bidet attachments and seats are designed for easy DIY installation. They connect to the existing water line with a T-adapter, and a full installation can often be completed in less than an hour with basic tools. Complex models may require professional help.

Many people continue to use a small amount of toilet paper to pat dry after using a bidet, but the volume is significantly reduced. Some advanced models also include a warm air dryer, which can eliminate the need for paper entirely.

Yes, bidets are more sanitary than toilet paper. They use a fresh stream of water to clean, which is a more hygienic method than wiping. Many bidets also have self-cleaning nozzles to ensure the device remains hygienic.

The argument for a bidet is strong, especially over so-called 'flushable' wipes. Wipes often cause severe clogs in plumbing and sewer systems, whereas bidets use water and don't create additional waste. They are more environmentally friendly and cost-effective.

Yes, many bidets include a specialized feminine wash setting with a gentler, wider spray. This feature is particularly useful for menstrual cycles, pregnancy, and postpartum cleaning, providing a more effective and soothing wash.

Bidets use a directed, precise stream of water, which is contained within the toilet bowl during use. The water pressure is adjustable, and the design ensures a targeted clean without creating a splash or mess outside of the bowl.

No, not all bidets require electricity. Basic, non-electric bidet attachments connect directly to the cold water supply. Electric models are needed for features like warm water, heated seats, and air dryers.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.