Skip to content

When should you not use compression?

4 min read

Wearing compression garments is a common practice for improving blood flow and reducing swelling, but it's not safe for everyone. Before using compression, it's crucial to understand when should you not use compression to avoid serious health risks.

Quick Summary

Certain serious medical conditions, including severe peripheral artery disease, uncontrolled congestive heart failure, and active skin infections, are strong contraindications for compression therapy due to the risk of worsening circulation or tissue damage.

Key Points

  • Peripheral Artery Disease: Never use compression for severe peripheral artery disease (PAD), as it can dangerously cut off blood flow to your legs and feet.

  • Decompensated Heart Failure: Avoid compression if you have severe or uncontrolled congestive heart failure, as it can overload the heart and cause fluid to back up in the lungs.

  • Active Skin Infections: Do not apply compression over active skin infections, such as cellulitis, as it can spread the infection and cause further tissue damage.

  • Neuropathy: Use caution with severe nerve damage or loss of sensation, as you may not be able to feel pressure points or skin irritation caused by improper fit.

  • Correct Sizing: A poor-fitting garment can cause more harm than good, leading to skin damage or cutting off circulation like a tourniquet. Always get professionally fitted for medical-grade compression.

  • Consult a Doctor: Always seek medical advice before starting compression therapy to confirm you do not have any contraindications and to determine the correct level of pressure for your condition.

In This Article

Understanding the purpose of compression therapy

Compression therapy, often in the form of stockings, socks, or bandages, works by applying gentle pressure to a limb. This pressure helps improve blood flow by aiding the veins and lymphatic vessels in moving fluid back toward the heart. It is commonly used to treat venous insufficiency, lymphedema, and for preventing deep vein thrombosis (DVT), particularly after surgery or during long periods of immobility.

The mechanism of action

  • Enhancing venous return: Compression exerts graduated pressure, highest at the ankle and decreasing up the leg, which helps push venous blood upwards against gravity. This prevents blood from pooling in the lower extremities.
  • Reducing swelling: By decreasing the pressure in the capillaries, compression reduces the amount of fluid leaking into the surrounding tissue, which helps manage edema.
  • Supporting the venous system: For individuals with weakened vein valves, compression acts as an external support, preventing venous reflux.

Serious medical conditions that prohibit compression

For some individuals, the benefits of compression are outweighed by significant health risks. It is paramount to consult a healthcare provider before beginning any compression regimen, as incorrect use can cause severe complications.

Peripheral artery disease (PAD)

One of the most critical contraindications is severe peripheral artery disease (PAD). This condition involves narrowed arteries that reduce blood flow to the limbs. Applying external compression in cases of severe PAD can further restrict the already compromised arterial blood flow, potentially leading to tissue damage, ulcers, or even amputation. Medical experts classify severe PAD using a very low ankle-brachial index (ABI), a measurement that compares blood pressure in the ankle to the arm.

Decompensated congestive heart failure (CHF)

For individuals with severe or decompensated congestive heart failure (NYHA Class IV), compression therapy is generally avoided. CHF means the heart is too weak to pump blood effectively. Compression can shift a large volume of blood from the legs back toward the heart, potentially overwhelming an already struggling heart and leading to dangerous fluid buildup in the lungs (pulmonary edema).

Severe neuropathy and sensory impairment

Severe nerve damage, such as diabetic neuropathy, can lead to a significant loss of sensation in the legs. This creates a high risk for compression therapy because the patient cannot feel if the garment is causing a problem, such as being too tight or bunching. This can lead to unnoticed skin breakdown, blistering, and severe pressure injuries.

Skin and tissue conditions

Applying compression directly over certain skin and soft-tissue conditions can exacerbate the problem. These include:

  • Active cellulitis: This is a serious bacterial skin infection that causes swelling, redness, and pain. Compression can spread the infection and cause significant discomfort. It should only be used after the infection is treated and cleared by a doctor, often to manage post-infection edema.
  • Oozing dermatitis or fragile skin: For patients with severe or oozing skin conditions, or those with very fragile skin, compression can cause further damage and complicate healing.
  • Gangrene: This is a condition involving the death of body tissue, and compression would be extremely dangerous.

Comparing high-risk versus safe use of compression

Understanding the nuanced differences between risky and safe applications is crucial. The following table contrasts scenarios based on common medical conditions.

Feature Risky Use Safe Use (with medical guidance)
Condition Severe Peripheral Artery Disease (PAD) Mild-to-moderate Venous Insufficiency
Circulation Status Severely impaired arterial blood flow Inefficient venous return from legs
Risk of Application Further reduction of blood supply, tissue damage Improved venous blood flow, reduced swelling
Symptom Profile Leg pain at rest, ulcers, cold limbs Swollen ankles, tired/heavy legs, varicose veins
Condition Decompensated Congestive Heart Failure (NYHA Class IV) Mild Edema with stable CHF (NYHA I-II)
Cardiac Status Heart is unable to handle increased fluid return Heart can handle carefully managed fluid return
Risk of Application Fluid overload, pulmonary edema Managed swelling, improved comfort
Symptom Profile Significant shortness of breath, severe swelling Mild leg swelling, fatigue
Condition Active cellulitis or open wounds Post-cellulitis or healed wounds
Skin Status Active infection, inflammation, open sores Healed skin, controlled chronic edema
Risk of Application Spreading infection, worsened tissue damage Preventing swelling and recurrence of infection

Important considerations and precautions

Even when a condition doesn't outright prohibit compression, significant precautions must be taken. This always requires a medical professional's oversight.

Correct sizing and fit

Improperly fitting compression garments are a common cause of complications, including skin irritation, discomfort, and even creating a tourniquet effect that restricts blood flow. A healthcare provider or trained fitter should always measure for and fit medical-grade compression garments to ensure correct and safe pressure application.

Monitoring for side effects

Patients should be taught to monitor their skin and symptoms carefully. Any signs of worsening pain, numbness, tingling, or skin discoloration (blue, red, or black) should be reported to a doctor immediately. Skin integrity checks, particularly for those with limited sensation, are vital.

Underlying causes of swelling

It is important to determine the root cause of swelling before using compression. Edema can be a symptom of many conditions, some of which require different treatments. For instance, swelling caused by a blood clot (DVT) may require a cautious and specific approach.

Conclusion: The critical role of medical guidance

While compression therapy is a safe and effective treatment for many, it is not a universally applicable solution. Ignoring the contraindications and using compression inappropriately can lead to severe, and in some cases, limb-threatening complications. Always consult with a qualified healthcare professional, such as a vascular surgeon, cardiologist, or phlebologist, to receive a proper diagnosis and treatment plan. A full medical assessment is the only way to ensure compression is both necessary and safe for your specific health needs. For more information on assessing vascular health, consult resources like the Vascular Cures website to find support and education on conditions related to blood vessel health and disease prevention.

Frequently Asked Questions

If you have diabetes, especially if you also have peripheral artery disease (PAD) or severe diabetic neuropathy (nerve damage), you should be extremely cautious and only use compression therapy under a doctor's strict supervision. Poor circulation and reduced sensation mean you may not feel skin damage.

For most people, it is not necessary and not recommended to wear compression stockings overnight while lying down, as gravity is no longer a major factor. Your doctor might, however, recommend it for certain severe conditions. Always follow medical advice.

In severe arterial disease, the arteries are already narrowed, and blood flow is compromised. Applying external compression can constrict these vessels even more, critically reducing the blood supply to the tissues and potentially causing ischemia or tissue death.

Signs that your compression garment is too tight include pain, numbness, tingling, discoloration of your toes or feet (becoming blue, black, or overly red), or swelling occurring above the top band.

No, compression should not be worn over an open, oozing wound or ulcer unless a healthcare provider specifically instructs it as part of a carefully managed wound care plan. Compression can complicate healing and increase the risk of infection.

Diagnosis of severe PAD should be left to a doctor. It is typically confirmed with a test called the ankle-brachial index (ABI). Symptoms can include painful leg cramping during exercise that resolves with rest, foot pain at rest, or non-healing sores on the legs and feet.

Decompensated congestive heart failure (NYHA Class IV) is a severe form where the heart can no longer pump enough blood to meet the body's needs. The condition is unstable and may present with severe symptoms like shortness of breath even at rest.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.