Why an Armpit Thermometer Can Be Wrong
When taking a temperature, the goal is to measure the body's internal, or core, temperature. The armpit, however, is a surface location, which inherently makes it less reliable than sites like the rectum or mouth. Unlike core temperature, the skin's temperature fluctuates more easily in response to both internal and external factors. This means that the reading on an armpit thermometer is a reflection of the skin's temperature, not a precise measure of the body's core. For this reason, medical professionals generally consider axillary measurements a screening tool rather than a diagnostic standard.
Factors Affecting Axillary Readings
Several variables can influence the outcome of an armpit temperature reading, leading to potential inaccuracies:
- Peripheral Vasoconstriction: At the onset of a fever, the body often constricts blood vessels in the extremities to conserve heat, a process known as peripheral vasoconstriction. This can cause the skin in the armpit to feel cooler even as the core body temperature is rising, resulting in a misleadingly low reading.
- Sweating and Evaporation: Sweat in the armpit can cause evaporative cooling, which lowers the temperature of the skin and can significantly skew the reading. A moist armpit will not give an accurate result.
- Incorrect Placement: The thermometer must be placed high in the center of the armpit and held securely against the skin. If the probe is not in direct contact with the skin or is touching clothing, the reading will be unreliable.
- Environmental Factors: The temperature of the room or exposure to cold air can impact the skin's surface temperature. This makes axillary readings particularly sensitive to external environmental conditions.
- Duration of Measurement: Failing to hold the thermometer in place for the full recommended time, typically 4 to 5 minutes for a standard digital thermometer, will produce an inaccurate, low reading. Some digital devices may beep sooner, but for axillary use, a longer hold time is often advised for a more stable temperature.
- Movement: A child's movement can break the secure contact between the thermometer and the skin, interrupting the measurement and causing an error.
How to Get the Most Accurate Armpit Reading
If using an armpit thermometer is the only option, following a proper technique can minimize errors. These steps can help improve the reliability of the reading:
- Use a Digital Thermometer: Avoid using old-style mercury thermometers, which are now considered a safety hazard. A reliable digital thermometer is the safest and most accurate option for axillary use.
- Prepare the Area: Ensure the armpit is dry before taking the temperature. If the person has been sweating or has recently bathed, wait for the skin to return to a normal state.
- Position Correctly: Place the tip of the thermometer high into the center of the armpit, ensuring it is in direct contact with the skin. Clothing should not be in the way.
- Hold Securely: Lower the arm and hold it snugly against the body. For a small child, holding them close can help keep their arm in place. The thermometer should be fully concealed by the armpit.
- Wait Long Enough: Leave the thermometer in place for the manufacturer's recommended time, or for a full 4 to 5 minutes, even after it beeps. This allows the reading to stabilize.
- Adjust the Reading: As axillary temperatures are typically lower, some pediatricians recommend adding a half to one degree Fahrenheit to the reading to estimate the core temperature. However, this is an estimation, not a precise measurement.
- Confirm the Reading: If a fever is suspected, or if the reading is concerning, confirm it with a more accurate method, such as a rectal, oral, or temporal artery thermometer.
Comparing Axillary to Other Thermometer Types
For an accurate temperature reading, especially in critical situations, other methods are often preferred. Here's a comparison of common thermometer types:
Measurement Method | Accuracy | Recommended For | Pros | Cons |
---|---|---|---|---|
Rectal | Most accurate, gold standard for infants | Infants (under 3 months for definitive results), children | Most reliable measure of core body temperature | Invasive, uncomfortable, requires proper technique |
Oral | Generally accurate for cooperative users | Children over 4-5 years old, adults | Non-invasive, quick results | Inaccurate if user has recently eaten, drank, or smoked; requires user cooperation |
Tympanic (Ear) | Good accuracy if used correctly | Older infants (>6 months), children, adults | Quick, easy to use | Accuracy can be affected by earwax, ear canal shape, or infection |
Temporal Artery (Forehead) | Generally accurate, can be affected by external factors | All ages, especially newborns | Quick, non-invasive, less disturbing to newborns | Can be affected by sweat, sunlight, or cold environment |
Axillary (Armpit) | Least accurate; best for initial screening | All ages for screening purposes | Non-invasive, safe, simple | Less accurate, readings often lower than core, susceptible to external factors |
A Note on Fever in Infants
For infants under 3 months of age, a rectal temperature is considered the gold standard for accuracy. An underarm reading is only a preliminary check. If a baby shows signs of illness, or if an axillary reading is elevated, it should be confirmed with a rectal temperature. Relying solely on an inaccurate armpit reading could lead to a delay in detecting a serious bacterial infection, which is a significant risk in this age group.
Conclusion
Yes, an armpit thermometer can be wrong, and its readings should always be viewed as an approximation rather than a definitive measurement. While convenient for an initial, non-invasive fever check, especially for older children and adults, it is the least accurate method. Factors such as sweat, environmental temperature, and improper technique can easily throw off the result. To ensure health decisions are based on the most reliable information, a more accurate method like rectal or oral thermometry should be used for confirmation, particularly for infants and young children. Understanding the limitations and proper usage of your thermometer is the first step toward accurate health monitoring. More detailed information can be found on authoritative health websites, such as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.