Skip to content

Can you smell if someone is ill? The science of detecting illness by scent

4 min read

In a 2023 study published in Scientific Reports, researchers found that humans could, with a slight but statistically significant accuracy, detect the body odor of individuals with a naturally occurring acute respiratory infection. This confirms long-held suspicions: you truly can smell if someone is ill.

Quick Summary

The body's metabolic processes change during illness, causing it to release different volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that subtly alter body odor. Our brains can instinctively process these chemical signals, acting as an ancient defense mechanism to prompt behavioral avoidance of contagious individuals, a finding supported by both human and animal studies.

Key Points

  • Immune System Activation Creates Scent: The body's immune response triggers the release of specific chemicals (VOCs) that alter body odor, even in the early stages of an illness.

  • Specific Illnesses Have Unique Odors: Conditions like diabetes, liver disease, and kidney failure produce distinct, medically recognizable smells due to altered metabolism.

  • Humans Can Detect Sickness Odors: Studies show that humans can detect subtle, unpleasant changes in the body odor of a sick person, though the effect is small.

  • Animals and Technology Exceed Human Ability: Dogs can be trained to detect disease odors with high accuracy, and 'e-noses' are being developed to provide non-invasive, scent-based diagnostics.

  • Diet and Hormones Affect Odor: Changes in diet and hormonal fluctuations from puberty, pregnancy, or menopause can also cause significant shifts in a person's body odor.

  • Distinctive Odor Changes Warrant Medical Attention: A significant or unusual change in body odor can be a symptom of an underlying medical condition and should be checked by a doctor.

In This Article

The Chemical Signals of Sickness

During an infection or metabolic disturbance, the body undergoes significant changes at a cellular level. This altered biochemistry produces specific volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are airborne molecules that are then released from the body through sweat, breath, and urine. These VOCs are what constitute a body's unique 'odorprint.' A healthy person's odorprint differs from that of a sick person, and these differences can be detected by other animals and, as research increasingly shows, by other humans.

How the Immune System Creates a Scent

One of the most compelling pieces of evidence comes from studies involving the activation of the innate immune system. In experiments, volunteers were injected with a substance that triggered a temporary inflammatory response without causing actual sickness. Just a few hours later, their body odor was perceived as more unpleasant and intense compared to samples from a control group. This suggests that the immune system's active state, rather than just the infection itself, can produce a detectable scent. The odor profile changes qualitatively, meaning the composition of the VOCs shifts, even if the overall amount doesn't change significantly.

Illnesses with Unique Odor Signatures

Specific medical conditions can produce distinctive and sometimes powerful odors due to changes in a person's metabolic processes. These odors can originate from different parts of the body, such as the breath, skin, or urine, and have been noted for centuries, though scientific verification is a more recent development.

  • Diabetic Ketoacidosis: Uncontrolled diabetes can lead to a state where the body burns fat for fuel, producing high levels of ketones. This results in a characteristic fruity or acetone-like smell on the breath, which is a medical emergency.
  • Liver Disease (Fetor Hepaticus): When the liver is failing, it cannot filter toxins properly. This can cause a distinctive musty, sweet, or fishy odor on the breath, often described as similar to garlic or rotten eggs.
  • Kidney Disease: The buildup of waste products, such as urea, can lead to an ammonia-like or fishy smell in the breath, as the kidneys struggle to filter the blood effectively.
  • Trimethylaminuria (Fish Odor Syndrome): A rare genetic metabolic disorder prevents the breakdown of the compound trimethylamine (TMA), causing a strong fishy odor in sweat, urine, and breath.
  • Infections: Certain bacterial infections can produce recognizable scents. For example, some Staphylococcus infections have been described as smelling like stale beer or old cheese, while E. coli can cause urine to smell like rotten fruit or vinegar.

How Can We Detect a Sickness Scent?

The Role of Animal Olfaction

While the human sense of smell is less acute than that of many animals, studying how animals detect disease has provided vital insights. Dogs, with their far superior sense of smell, have been trained to detect the presence of specific cancers, diabetes, and even malaria by sniffing samples of breath, urine, or clothing. The success of these dogs proves that distinct, disease-specific VOCs exist and can be consistently identified.

The Future of Electronic Noses (e-Noses)

Scientists are developing specialized technology, known as electronic noses, to mimic and surpass human and animal olfaction. These devices use sensor arrays to detect and analyze VOC patterns in samples like breath, urine, and skin. Early studies have shown promising results, with e-noses able to accurately differentiate between different respiratory diseases, inflammatory conditions, and various types of cancer. While still in the research phase, this technology holds potential for non-invasive, early disease detection.

Factors Influencing Body Odor

  1. Metabolic Changes: Diseases alter metabolic pathways, leading to the production of different VOCs. This is why conditions like diabetes and liver disease have such distinct smells.
  2. Hormonal Fluctuations: Changes in hormones, such as those during pregnancy or menopause, can affect the composition of sweat and the activity of skin bacteria, altering body odor.
  3. Diet: What you eat directly impacts your body odor. Consumption of certain foods, like fenugreek or cruciferous vegetables, can release distinct aromatic compounds.
  4. Microbiome: The bacteria on your skin and in your gut play a significant role. Your skin's resident bacteria break down sweat, creating the odors we perceive. Changes in your microbiome can therefore alter your scent.

Disease Odor Comparison Table

Condition Typical Odor Source Cause
Diabetic Ketoacidosis Fruity, Acetone Breath, Sweat Buildup of ketones from fat metabolism
Advanced Liver Disease Musty, Sweet, Fishy Breath, Urine Toxin buildup (e.g., mercaptans) from impaired liver function
Kidney Failure Ammonia, Urine-like Breath Buildup of urea and waste products in the body
Trimethylaminuria Fishy, Rotting Sweat, Urine, Breath Inability to break down trimethylamine
Typhoid Fever Baked Bread Skin Metabolic changes associated with infection

Conclusion

While we don't consciously diagnose illness with our noses, the subtle shifts in body odor caused by metabolic changes are real and detectable. This innate, subtle ability to perceive sickness could be an evolutionary defense mechanism to avoid contagious individuals. From historical observations to modern scientific studies using sophisticated electronic equipment, the link between disease and scent is clear. Although smelling sickness is not a substitute for professional medical diagnosis, a noticeable and persistent change in body odor should always be evaluated by a healthcare provider.

For more information on the groundbreaking research connecting smell and disease, refer to scientific studies, such as this one on Human Scent as a First-Line Defense Against Disease.

Frequently Asked Questions

When the body fights an illness, its metabolic processes change, producing different volatile organic compounds (VOCs). These compounds are released through sweat and breath, causing a subtle but detectable change in a person's scent.

No, you should never rely on your sense of smell alone for medical diagnosis. While humans can detect subtle illness cues, a distinct change in body odor is a symptom that should be evaluated by a medical professional, not self-diagnosed.

Not all illnesses produce a strong, noticeable smell, but many can cause subtle changes in volatile organic compounds (VOCs). More significant metabolic disorders and infections are more likely to cause a distinct change in body odor.

A fruity or acetone-like breath smell in a diabetic person can signal diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA), a serious condition. It occurs when the body, lacking enough insulin, starts burning fat for energy, producing ketones that have this characteristic scent.

Yes, dogs have a superior sense of smell and have been successfully trained to detect the unique volatile organic compounds (VOCs) associated with certain cancers and other diseases in samples like breath and urine.

Electronic noses, or e-noses, are technological devices designed to detect and identify complex scent patterns, including those associated with different diseases. They are being developed as a non-invasive tool for diagnostic purposes.

Research suggests that this is possible. Studies have found that body odor changes can be detected just hours after the immune system is activated, potentially before a person even feels sick.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.