Skip to content

What is the difference between a pilonidal cyst and Coccydynia?

5 min read

While both a pilonidal cyst and Coccydynia cause pain near the tailbone, one is a skin condition, while the other is a musculoskeletal issue. This distinction is critical for receiving effective treatment and underscores the importance of a proper medical diagnosis when experiencing pain in this sensitive area.

Quick Summary

A pilonidal cyst is a fluid-filled sac under the skin containing hair and debris, while Coccydynia is inflammation and pain of the coccyx, or tailbone bone itself.

Key Points

  • Location is key: A pilonidal cyst is a skin issue in the buttock crease, while Coccydynia is pain originating from the coccyx bone itself.

  • Visual cues matter: A pilonidal cyst may present with a visible lump, pit, or draining fluid, which are not typical for Coccydynia.

  • Underlying cause: Cysts are caused by an infection from trapped hair and debris, whereas Coccydynia is a musculoskeletal problem often caused by trauma or stress.

  • Different treatment approaches: Treatment for a pilonidal cyst focuses on managing the infection (drainage, surgery), while Coccydynia is treated with pain management, physical therapy, and injections.

  • Diagnosis requires professional help: A medical professional's physical exam and potential imaging are necessary to distinguish between the two conditions and ensure correct treatment.

In This Article

Understanding a Pilonidal Cyst

A pilonidal cyst is a sac of tissue that forms at the top of the buttocks crease, near the tailbone. While it often begins as an asymptomatic pit or dimple in the skin, it can become infected, leading to a painful abscess. The name “pilonidal” means “nest of hair,” a nod to the common discovery of ingrown hair and skin debris trapped inside the cyst.

Causes and Risk Factors

The primary cause of a pilonidal cyst is believed to be loose hairs puncturing the skin and becoming embedded. The body’s immune response creates a cyst around the trapped hair and debris. Several factors can increase the risk of developing this condition:

  • Prolonged Sitting: Spending extended periods sitting, such as for a job or while driving, puts pressure and friction on the tailbone area, which can force hair into the skin.
  • Excess Body Hair: Individuals with thick, stiff, or coarse body hair are more susceptible.
  • Gender and Age: Pilonidal cysts are more common in young adult males, especially those between 20 and 35 years of age.
  • Obesity: Carrying excess weight places additional pressure on the tailbone region.
  • Hereditary Factors: A family history of pilonidal cysts can increase your risk, potentially due to inherited hair type.

Symptoms

The symptoms of a pilonidal cyst become prominent when it gets infected:

  • A visible, painful, swollen lump or abscess near the tailbone.
  • Redness and tenderness of the surrounding skin.
  • Pus or blood draining from an opening in the skin, which may have a foul odor.
  • Pain that worsens with sitting or standing.
  • Fever, fatigue, or nausea in severe cases of infection.

Understanding Coccydynia

Coccydynia, or coccygodynia, is a medical term for pain in the coccyx, the triangular bone at the base of the spine commonly known as the tailbone. Unlike a pilonidal cyst, Coccydynia is a musculoskeletal condition involving the bone and its surrounding ligaments and muscles. The pain can range from a dull ache to a sharp, stabbing sensation.

Causes and Risk Factors

The pain associated with Coccydynia is often a result of direct trauma or repetitive stress on the tailbone:

  • Trauma: A fall directly onto the tailbone can cause a bruise, fracture, or dislocation.
  • Childbirth: During the final stages of pregnancy and childbirth, hormonal changes soften the area around the coccyx. The passage of a large baby can overstretch the surrounding ligaments and muscles, leading to pain.
  • Repetitive Strain: Activities like cycling or rowing that involve repetitive leaning and stretching of the lower spine can strain the tailbone.
  • Poor Posture: Sitting with poor posture, especially for long periods, can increase pressure on the coccyx.
  • Weight Fluctuations: Both obesity and being underweight can be contributing factors. Excess weight puts more stress on the coccyx, while a lack of fat in the buttocks can reduce cushioning.
  • Degenerative Changes: Age-related changes like arthritis can also cause tailbone pain.

Symptoms

The symptoms of Coccydynia are centered around bone and joint pain, rather than skin issues:

  • Localized pain or tenderness directly at the tailbone.
  • Pain that worsens when moving from a sitting to a standing position.
  • Increased pain during prolonged sitting, especially on hard surfaces.
  • Discomfort during bowel movements or sexual intercourse.
  • Tenderness when the doctor presses on the tailbone area during a physical exam.

Key Differences at a Glance: Comparison Table

Feature Pilonidal Cyst Coccydynia
Nature A skin abscess or pit, a soft-tissue condition. Inflammation or injury of the coccyx bone and its surrounding attachments, a musculoskeletal condition.
Location In the skin at the top of the buttock crease, slightly above the tailbone. Directly on or around the tailbone itself, at the very bottom of the spine.
Key Symptoms Painful, swollen lump with potential pus drainage, redness, and foul odor. Pain localized to the tailbone bone that worsens with pressure or positional changes.
Physical Signs A visible lump, pit, or draining fistula in the skin. Pain upon palpation (touching) of the bone. Usually no external skin changes like a lump or redness.
Primary Cause Ingrown hairs and debris leading to infection. Trauma (falls), childbirth, repetitive strain, or poor posture.
Diagnostic Tools Visual inspection and physical exam of the skin. Physical exam (including digital rectal exam) and imaging like X-rays or MRI.

How is a Pilonidal Cyst Diagnosed and Treated?

Diagnosis for a pilonidal cyst is primarily visual and tactile. A doctor will inspect the area for a visible dimple, sinus tract, or infected abscess. They can often feel the hard, inflamed lump beneath the skin.

Treatment depends on the severity. Mild cases may resolve with warm compresses and good hygiene. Infected cysts (abscesses) often require incision and drainage, where the doctor numbs the area, makes a small incision, and drains the pus. In cases of chronic or recurrent cysts, surgical removal of the cyst and tracts may be necessary to prevent future flare-ups. Minimally invasive procedures also exist for recurrent cases.

For more detailed information on pilonidal cysts, including treatment options, you can consult resources from major medical institutions like the Mayo Clinic website.

How is Coccydynia Diagnosed and Treated?

Diagnosing Coccydynia often requires a more detailed approach to rule out other causes. A doctor will conduct a physical exam, including palpating the coccyx to check for pain and mobility. A digital rectal exam may be performed to assess the coccyx's movement and rule out other issues. Imaging studies like X-rays, MRIs, or CT scans can also help identify bone spurs, fractures, or other abnormalities.

Treatment for Coccydynia is typically non-surgical and focuses on pain management and healing:

  • Conservative Management:
    • Using specialized cushions (donut or wedge-shaped) to relieve pressure.
    • Avoiding prolonged sitting on hard surfaces.
    • Applying ice or heat to the area to reduce inflammation.
  • Medications:
    • Over-the-counter pain relievers and anti-inflammatories, such as NSAIDs.
    • Corticosteroid injections into the joint for more significant pain relief.
  • Physical Therapy: Exercises and stretches can help improve posture and strengthen supporting muscles in the pelvic floor.
  • Surgery: In rare, severe cases that do not respond to other treatments, surgical removal of the coccyx (coccygectomy) may be considered.

The Critical Importance of Correct Diagnosis

Misdiagnosing a pilonidal cyst as Coccydynia, or vice versa, can lead to incorrect and ineffective treatment. For example, treating a pilonidal abscess with physical therapy and a donut cushion will not resolve the underlying infection, which could worsen and become a chronic issue. Conversely, draining a non-existent cyst will not provide relief for true coccyx bone pain caused by trauma or inflammation.

Since the symptoms for both conditions can be similar and involve pain in the same general region, a medical professional is crucial for accurate identification. A doctor can differentiate between the soft-tissue infection of a pilonidal cyst and the bony or joint-related pain of Coccydynia through a proper physical examination and, if necessary, diagnostic imaging.

Next Steps for Diagnosis and Treatment

If you are experiencing pain in the tailbone area, it is essential to seek medical advice from a qualified healthcare professional. Do not attempt to self-diagnose or treat the condition. A doctor can conduct a thorough examination and recommend the appropriate diagnostic tests to determine the cause of your pain. Early and accurate diagnosis is the first step toward effective treatment and long-term relief.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, a pilonidal cyst does not cause Coccydynia, and vice versa. While both can cause pain in the same general area, they are distinct conditions with different causes and affected tissues.

Yes, prolonged sitting is a risk factor for both conditions, though for different reasons. It can cause friction that leads to a pilonidal cyst and puts excess pressure on the coccyx, contributing to Coccydynia.

Surgery is often required for chronic or infected pilonidal cysts, but milder cases can sometimes be managed with conservative treatments like warm compresses and drainage. A doctor can determine the best course of action.

For Coccydynia, sitting on a donut-shaped or wedge-shaped cushion is often recommended to take pressure off the tailbone. Taking frequent breaks to stand or walk is also helpful.

While it's possible, an experienced physician can usually differentiate between the two with a thorough physical exam. The presence of a visible lump, pit, or drainage points toward a pilonidal cyst, while pinpoint tenderness on the bone itself indicates Coccydynia.

No, a pilonidal cyst is not contagious. It is caused by ingrown hairs and is a localized skin condition, not an infectious disease that can spread from person to person.

Yes, childbirth is a common cause of Coccydynia. Hormonal changes and pressure during delivery can stretch or injure the ligaments and muscles around the coccyx, leading to pain.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.