Understanding the Concept of 'Pure' Water
In chemistry, a pure substance contains only one type of molecule. For water, this means only H₂O. In reality, all water, including tap and bottled water, contains various dissolved solids, ions, and minerals. Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) is a measure of these substances. While low TDS is often associated with purity, the source of the dissolved solids—whether beneficial minerals or harmful contaminants—is what truly matters for health.
Distilled Water: The Chemical Gold Standard
Distillation is a water purification method that mimics the earth's natural hydrologic cycle of evaporation and condensation. The water is boiled, and the steam is captured and condensed back into a liquid, leaving behind contaminants, minerals, and other dissolved solids. This process results in extremely pure H₂O. For this reason, distilled water is often used in laboratory settings, for medical equipment like CPAP machines, and in appliances where mineral buildup could cause damage.
- The Process: Heating water to create steam, which is then re-condensed into liquid water.
- Results: Near-total removal of minerals, salts, and contaminants.
- Drawbacks: The resulting water can have a 'flat' taste due to the lack of minerals and, for long-term daily drinking, can pose risks of mineral deficiencies if not balanced with diet.
Deionized Water: A Different Approach to Purity
Deionized (DI) water is created by removing all mineral ions (like cations and anions) through an electrically charged process called ion exchange. While it removes ions, it doesn't necessarily remove uncharged organic molecules or microorganisms. For this reason, DI water for consumption should typically undergo additional purification processes like reverse osmosis first. It is primarily used in industrial and scientific applications where the absence of ions is critical.
Reverse Osmosis: A Popular Drinking Water Solution
Reverse osmosis (RO) is a highly effective purification method that uses pressure to force water through a semipermeable membrane. This membrane blocks most dissolved salts, inorganic matter, and large molecules, including many bacteria and viruses. Many multi-stage RO systems combine a pre-filter, RO membrane, and post-carbon filter to remove a wide range of contaminants, including chlorine, pesticides, and heavy metals.
The Reverse Osmosis System
- Pre-filtration: Removes larger sediments and chlorine.
- Reverse Osmosis Membrane: The core filter that blocks most dissolved solids.
- Post-carbon Filter: Polishes the water to remove any lingering tastes or odors.
- Remineralization: Some high-end systems add back a balanced blend of minerals for better taste and health benefits.
Comparing Water Purification Methods
Feature | Distilled Water | Deionized Water | Reverse Osmosis (RO) Water |
---|---|---|---|
Purity Level | Extremely high; near-zero TDS | Extremely low ion count; may retain uncharged particles | Very high purity; >99% contaminant reduction in good systems |
Method | Boiling and condensation | Ion exchange | Pressure through a semipermeable membrane |
Removes Minerals? | Yes, completely | Yes, completely removes ionized minerals | Yes, but some systems add them back |
Taste | Often described as flat or bland | Bland due to mineral removal | Can be neutral or enhanced with minerals |
Use Case | Medical equipment, laboratory, industrial | Laboratory, microelectronics, industrial | Drinking water, cooking, aquariums |
The Health Debate: Is the Purest Water the Healthiest?
While distilled and deionized water are the purest in terms of total dissolved solids, this doesn't automatically make them the healthiest option for daily drinking. For long-term consumption, the complete lack of minerals like calcium and magnesium can be a concern, though most people get sufficient minerals from food. The World Health Organization has even noted that water with extremely low concentrations of TDS may have a flat, insipid taste that some find unacceptable. For everyday hydration, purified water with a balanced mineral content is often preferred. Many RO systems on the market offer a final stage that reintroduces beneficial minerals, creating a water that is both clean and pleasant to drink.
Ultimately, the 'best' water depends on your specific needs. If you're using it for a CPAP machine or scientific experiment, the mineral-free nature of distilled water is ideal. For daily drinking, a high-quality, multi-stage reverse osmosis system provides a balance of effective contaminant removal and good taste, and many people find it to be the perfect combination of pure and healthy.
Learn more about water purification techniques at the EPA's website