Skip to content

Should You Go to Work or Stay Home Sick? The Definitive Guide

5 min read

According to a study cited by Sharp HealthCare, a sick employee can spread their germs to up to 60% of commonly touched surfaces in the workplace in just four hours. Faced with a cough or a fever, the choice of 'should you go to work or stay home sick?' is a decision that impacts not just you, but everyone around you.

Quick Summary

This article outlines critical factors for deciding whether to stay home sick, addressing common symptoms, workplace ethics, and the impact of 'presenteeism' on productivity and health. It details how to determine contagiousness and the best ways to communicate an absence.

Key Points

  • Prioritize Rest for Faster Recovery: Ignoring your body's need for rest can prolong your illness and weaken your immune system, making staying home the more efficient path to recovery.

  • Prevent Contagion at Work: If you have a fever, vomiting, or other highly contagious symptoms, staying home is essential to prevent spreading germs to your coworkers and vulnerable individuals.

  • Recognize the Signs of Presenteeism: Attempting to work while very ill often leads to reduced focus, errors, and overall lower productivity, costing more than taking a day to rest.

  • Communicate Effectively with Your Manager: Inform your supervisor as early as possible with a brief, honest update on your absence, following company protocol for clear communication.

  • Consider Remote Work Limitations: Even when working from home, evaluate whether your symptoms genuinely prevent you from being productive; if so, a proper sick day is still necessary.

  • Don't Ignore Mental Health: Mental health is just as important as physical health, and taking a sick day for burnout or anxiety is a valid reason to rest and recuperate.

  • Protect Vulnerable Populations: Going to work sick can put coworkers and customers with compromised immune systems at serious health risk, so err on the side of caution.

In This Article

Understanding the Risks of Presenteeism

For many, working while sick is seen as a sign of dedication or a necessity due to heavy workloads or fear of falling behind. This phenomenon is known as “presenteeism,” where an employee is physically present at work but unable to perform their duties effectively due to illness. This can have significant negative consequences for both the individual and the organization. For the sick employee, overexertion can weaken the immune system, prolonging recovery and potentially leading to more severe or chronic health issues down the line. For the workplace, presenteeism can be more costly than absenteeism, with reduced productivity, increased errors, and a higher risk of spreading germs to coworkers. Experts report that presenteeism costs the U.S. economy billions of dollars each year in lost productivity.

The Impact on Your Health

Your body uses symptoms like fever and fatigue to signal that it needs to rest and recover. Ignoring these signals and pushing through can compromise your immune response. Instead of fighting off the illness efficiently, your body must also contend with the stress and energy demands of work. This extended period of vulnerability can lead to a more severe or drawn-out illness. Resting properly allows your body to dedicate its resources to healing, helping you get back on your feet faster and stronger.

The Ripple Effect on Coworkers

Going to work when you're contagious guarantees that your germs will spread. In shared office spaces, where common areas like doorknobs, phones, and break rooms are frequently touched, transmission is almost certain. This can lead to an office-wide outbreak, causing multiple employees to get sick and creating a much larger disruption for the company. Moreover, spreading illness puts high-risk individuals—such as those who are immunocompromised, pregnant, or have underlying health conditions—at serious risk of complications.

When Is It Absolutely Necessary to Stay Home?

While some mild symptoms like a simple dry cough or mild congestion might not always require a day off, several clear indicators mean you should stay home to prevent further spread and promote your own recovery. The CDC offers specific guidance on respiratory viruses that can help.

  • Fever: A temperature of 100.4°F (38°C) or higher is a clear sign that your body is fighting a significant infection. Stay home until you've been fever-free for at least 24 hours without using fever-reducing medication.
  • Vomiting and Diarrhea: Gastrointestinal illnesses like norovirus are highly contagious. Stay home until at least 24 hours after your last episode to prevent rapid transmission.
  • Persistent Coughing or Sneezing: If your cough is heavy, productive, or frequent, it’s best to stay home. Contagious illnesses can be spread through respiratory droplets released by coughing and sneezing.
  • Extreme Fatigue and Body Aches: Widespread body aches, chills, and overwhelming fatigue are often symptoms of more serious illnesses like the flu or COVID-19. Your body is telling you it needs rest.
  • Mental Health Concerns: Illness isn't always physical. Taking a mental health day for burnout, stress, or anxiety is just as valid a reason to call in sick. Your ability to focus and perform can be severely impacted by mental distress.

The Role of Remote Work

The rise of remote work has introduced a new layer of complexity to the sick day decision. For many, working from home while feeling unwell seems like a compromise, but it's important to be honest with yourself about your capacity. If your symptoms significantly impact your cognitive function and ability to focus, working from home may just prolong your illness and reduce your productivity. A useful question to ask is, "If I had to go into the office today, would I take a sick day?" If the answer is yes, then you should take a sick day, even if you are working remotely.

Comparison: Staying Home vs. Working While Sick

Aspect Staying Home (Resting) Working While Sick (Presenteeism)
Recovery Time Often faster, as the body can focus on healing. Longer, as the body is stressed and energy is diverted to work.
Productivity Day of absence may require catching up later, but overall productivity is higher. Dramatically reduced due to poor concentration, fatigue, and potential errors.
Germ Spread Stops or significantly minimizes the spread of contagious illness to others. All but guarantees the spread of germs, causing an office-wide ripple effect.
Coworker Perception Generally appreciated for protecting the health of the team. May be viewed as irresponsible for risking the health of colleagues.
High-Risk Individuals Protects coworkers, clients, or customers with compromised immune systems. Puts vulnerable individuals at higher risk of severe illness or complications.
Stress Levels Reduces stress by allowing rest and recovery. Increases stress from attempting to perform duties while unwell.

How to Communicate Your Absence

When you need to take a sick day, clear and professional communication is key. Follow your company's established protocol, which is usually outlined in the employee handbook. Here are some general best practices:

  • Notify your supervisor as soon as possible: Send an email or make a phone call to alert them before your workday is scheduled to begin. This allows them to plan for your absence.
  • Keep it brief and professional: There is no need to provide gory details about your symptoms. A simple message like, "I'm not feeling well and need to take the day off to recover," is sufficient.
  • Provide a return estimate: If possible, give a rough estimate of when you expect to be back. If it's a multi-day illness, inform them that you will keep them updated.
  • Prepare for your absence: If you're able, provide a quick handover of urgent tasks to a coworker or a summary of ongoing projects. Set an out-of-office message for your email.

Conclusion: Prioritize Your Health

The notion that working through illness demonstrates admirable work ethic is an outdated and harmful myth. In reality, it poses a significant risk to your own health and the well-being of those around you. The decision of whether you should go to work or stay home sick requires careful consideration of your symptoms, your contagiousness, and your overall capacity to be productive. By prioritizing rest and recovery, you are making the responsible choice for both your short-term healing and long-term health, while also fostering a safer, healthier workplace culture.

For more detailed health guidelines, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is an excellent resource: Preventing Spread of Respiratory Viruses When You're Sick.

Frequently Asked Questions

A fever of 100.4°F (38°C) or higher is a clear indicator that you should stay home. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommends staying home for at least 24 hours after your fever is gone without taking fever-reducing medication.

If you have mild cold symptoms like a stuffy nose or a slight sore throat without a fever, you may be able to go to work. However, you are most contagious during the first 2-3 days, so it's best to consider staying home if your symptoms are pronounced. If you do go in, practice strict hygiene to avoid spreading germs.

For gastrointestinal illnesses, you should stay home for at least 24 hours after your last episode of vomiting or diarrhea. This is because these illnesses are often highly contagious and can be spread rapidly.

Presenteeism is when employees come to work while sick but are not fully productive due to their illness. It's a problem because it can lead to decreased work quality, prolonged recovery for the individual, and the spread of illness to coworkers, often being more costly than simply taking a sick day.

While remote work offers flexibility, you should still evaluate if your illness prevents you from performing your tasks effectively. If your cognitive function is impaired, taking a proper sick day is better for your recovery. Ask yourself, 'if I had to go into the office, would I take a sick day?' If the answer is yes, take the day off.

Notify your supervisor as soon as possible via your company's preferred method (email, phone call, etc.). Keep the message brief and professional, simply stating you are unwell and need to take the day off to recover. You don't need to share excessive details about your illness.

Yes, taking a day for mental health reasons like burnout or severe stress is a valid use of a sick day. Mental well-being is critical for overall health and productivity. You can simply state that you are not feeling well and need time to recover.

References

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8

Medical Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice.